- Free Shipping
- Price Protection
- Easy Returns
Roof Rack Comparison Guide: Which System Is Right for Your Vehicle?
| May 2025
Finding the perfect roof rack system for your vehicle can be confusing with so many options available. This comprehensive guide breaks down the differences between factory OEM racks, aftermarket crossbars, and platform-style overland racks to help you make the best choice for your specific needs.
Understanding Your Vehicle's Roof Rack Options
- Sedans: Most don't come with roof racks from factory
- Crossovers & SUVs: Often come with side-mounted roof rails (running front to back) or optional crossbars
- Full-sized SUVs: Similar to crossovers with rails or crossbars options
Whether you're driving a compact Subaru, a mid-size CX-5, CRV, RAV4, or a full-sized Suburban or Expedition, understanding your base configuration is the first step to choosing the right rack system.
Factory OEM Crossbars: The Pros and Cons
Characteristics of Factory Racks:
- Usually thinner than aftermarket options
- Often curved to follow the roofline (lower on edges, higher in center)
- Bars typically connect directly into mounting feet
- Designed to stay within the width of the roof
Advantages:
- Lower profile, factory-matched look
- Reduced wind noise
- Better aerodynamics and fuel economy
- Sometimes available at good dealer discounts
Disadvantages:
- The curved design can make mounting cargo boxes problematic (can warp the bottom of boxes like Thule Motion)
- Limited strength for heavy loads like rooftop tents
- Narrower width means less usable space
- Lack of utility features like channels or tie-down points
When manufacturers design OEM racks, their primary concerns are aerodynamics and noise reduction rather than versatility and load capacity. This is why they create lower, curved, and more streamlined systems.
If you're looking for that factory appearance while wanting better performance, options like the Thule Wing Bar Edge offer a similar low-profile design with improved functionality.
Aftermarket Crossbars: More Strength and Utility
Aftermarket crossbars from companies like Thule and Rhino Rack offer significant advantages for those who need more from their roof rack system.
Key Features:
- Extended Bars: Crossbars extend past the mounting feet, creating stronger support and tie-down points
- Straight Design: No curve means easier mounting of accessories
- Wider Footprint: More usable space for multiple accessories
- C-Channels: Most feature channels for mounting accessories and rubber strips for load stability
The Strength Advantage
When crossbars extend past the mounting feet, weight is distributed directly above the feet rather than creating leverage points. This makes aftermarket systems significantly stronger - critical if you're planning to mount a rooftop tent or carry heavy loads.
Real Estate Matters
The wider design of aftermarket crossbars means you can fit more on your roof. Want to mount a large Thule Force cargo box AND a couple of bike carriers? This is typically only possible with a full-width aftermarket system.
Wind Noise Concerns?
Despite standing taller than OEM options, quality aftermarket crossbars like the Thule Wing Bar are engineered for minimal wind noise. We rarely receive complaints about noise when these systems are properly installed.
Fuel Economy Impact
In our testing, even on range-sensitive electric vehicles like the Chevy Bolt, properly installed aftermarket roof racks like the Thule Wing Bar showed negligible impact on range. Check out our YouTube testing video for more details.
Platform Style/Overland Racks: Maximum Versatility
Platform racks (also called tray or basket systems) from brands like Prinzu, Leitner, Front Runner, and Rhino Rack offer a completely different approach to roof storage.
When to Choose a Platform Rack:
- You need to carry non-standard items (spare tires, gas cans, storage totes)
- You want to mount multiple accessories (light bars, antennas, satellite dishes)
- You prefer the rugged overland/safari aesthetic
- You need maximum strength for heavy loads
Brand Differences Matter - Platform racks vary slightly between manufacturers:
- Front Runner: Features shallow basket-like design with raised outer rails
- Rhino Rack Pioneer: Flat design that mimics multiple crossbars, compatible with standard mounting hardware
- Prinzu/Sherpa: Ultra-low profile with excellent aerodynamics, but often requires brand-specific mounting brackets
- Thule CapRock: A modular platform system with an impressive 330 lbs weight capacity and integrated T-slots throughout. Available in multiple sizes (S, M, L, XL) to fit virtually any vehicle, and can be easily converted to a cargo basket with optional side railings. Compatible with existing crossbar systems using adapter kits
- Leitner: Features the thickest and strongest crossbars in the industry with a patented mounting system that allows you to position crossbars anywhere within the tray surround—you can even remove center bars completely while maintaining full load capacity, or add more bars for a completely flat surface, or position bars to accommodate a sunroof
The Mounting Challenge
Unlike crossbars, most accessories aren't designed to directly mount to platform racks. While you can mount virtually anything, you'll often need special adapters or creative solutions. Even standard accessories like roof tents, bike racks, or awnings typically require specific mounting brackets.
For example, the Prinzu system looks fantastic with its low profile and wind fairing, but you'll almost always need Prinzu-specific brackets to mount accessories due to its proximity to the roof.
Wind Noise Consideration
It's important to note that platform/tray systems almost always create more wind noise than crossbars as you're adding significantly more material to your roof. Most brands offer wind deflectors (either included or as an option) which help reduce noise, but if wind noise is a primary concern, be aware that it will be noticeable regardless of which platform system you choose.
Installation Considerations: What to Expect
Factory OEM Racks
- Difficulty Level: Easy to Moderate
- Time Required: 30-60 minutes
- Tools Needed: Basic hand tools, often just those included with the rack
- Special Considerations: Usually designed specifically for your vehicle with pre-determined mounting points
Aftermarket Crossbars
- Difficulty Level: Moderate
- Time Required: 1-2 hours for first-time installation
- Tools Needed: Basic hand tools - everything you need is typically included in the kit
- Special Considerations: The systems come with detailed instructions and innovative design features that make proper positioning straightforward - if you can assemble IKEA furniture, you can install a Thule or Rhino Rack system
Platform/Overland Racks
- Difficulty Level: Moderate to Complex
- Time Required: 2-4 hours (sometimes more for complex systems)
- Tools Needed: Comprehensive tool set, sometimes including power tools
- Special Considerations: May require multiple people for positioning; some systems require drilling or other modifications to your vehicle's roof, which requires careful consideration
Many of our customers find that professional installation provides peace of mind, especially for platform systems or when mounting expensive accessories like rooftop tents. Our installation service ensures your rack is perfectly positioned and secured to manufacturer specifications.
Comparison Chart: Factory vs Aftermarket vs Platform Racks
To help you quickly compare the different roof rack options, we've created this comprehensive comparison chart:
| Feature | Factory OEM Racks | Aftermarket Crossbars | Platform/Overland Racks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Profile Height | Low profile | Medium height | Highest profile |
| Weight Capacity | Low to Medium (typically 100-150 lbs) |
Medium (typically 150-200 lbs) |
Highest (200-300+ lbs) |
| Bar Design | Usually curved | Straight | Flat platform with multiple crossbars |
| Bar Extension | Bars end at mounting feet | Bars extend past mounting feet |
Full platform coverage |
| Wind Noise | Lowest | Low to Medium (model dependent) |
High (wind deflectors help but don't eliminate) |
| Fuel Economy Impact | Minimal | Minimal to Moderate | Moderate |
| Mounting Versatility | Limited | Good | Excellent |
| Accessory Compatibility | Basic accessories only | Most standard accessories | Non-standard items plus adapters for standard accessories |
| Installation Complexity | Simple | Moderate | Complex |
| Aesthetic | Factory integrated | Utilitarian | Rugged/Overland/Safari |
| Price Range (CAD) | $400-900 | $700-1,200+ | $1,800-3,500+ |
Making Your Decision: Which Rack Type Is Right For You?
Best Use Cases for Each Rack Type:
- Basic Carrying Needs (ski carriers, occasional luggage): Factory OEM racks may be sufficient
- Regular Heavy Use (cargo boxes, lumber, ladders, bikes): Aftermarket crossbars will provide better utility
- Specialized Gear/Overlanding (non-standard items, multiple accessories): Platform racks offer maximum flexibility
Frequently Asked Questions About Roof Racks
Do roof racks damage your vehicle?
When properly installed, quality roof racks will not damage your vehicle. Most systems are designed to work with your vehicle's specific mounting points or existing roof rails. However, exceeding weight limits or improper installation can potentially cause damage.
Will a roof rack significantly affect my fuel economy?
Our testing shows that modern aerodynamic crossbars like the Thule Wing Bar have minimal impact on fuel economy - even on EVs like the Chevy Bolt. Platform racks will have a more noticeable impact, but typically less than 10% reduction in efficiency.
How much wind noise should I expect?
- Factory OEM racks: Specifically designed to minimize wind noise
- Aftermarket crossbars: Quality options like Thule Wing Bars are engineered for minimal noise when properly installed
- Platform/tray racks: Will produce noticeable wind noise due to the amount of material added to your roof. Wind deflectors help reduce this noise but won't eliminate it completely. If wind noise is a major concern, platform racks may not be your best option.
Can I install a roof rack myself?
Most aftermarket crossbar systems are designed for DIY installation and come with detailed instructions. Platform racks often require more time and mechanical skill - some customers prefer professional installation for these systems.
Can I use my factory crossbars with a rooftop tent?
We generally don't recommend mounting rooftop tents on factory crossbars due to their lower weight capacity and design limitations. For rooftop tents, we strongly recommend aftermarket crossbars or platform racks rated for the specific tent's weight.
How much weight can my roof rack hold?
This varies significantly between vehicles and rack systems:
- Most factory racks: 100-150 lbs (static load)
- Quality aftermarket crossbars: 150-200 lbs
- Platform/overland racks: 200-300+ lbs (some up to 800 lbs when stationary)
Always check both your vehicle's roof weight limit and your specific rack system's rating.
What about budget or "no-name" roof racks available online?
We often get asked about the significantly cheaper roof rack options available on marketplaces like Amazon. While these can be tempting based on price alone, we generally advise caution:
- Safety concerns: Many budget brands don't undergo the same rigorous testing as established manufacturers
- Reliability issues: We've seen numerous failures with mounting hardware, locking mechanisms, and overall durability
- Installation challenges: Often come with minimal instructions and poor-fitting components
- Limited warranty support: Many offer minimal or difficult-to-claim warranty coverage
- Certification questions: Many lack proper certifications for crash safety standards
While there's certainly a price premium for established brands like Thule, Rhino Rack, Prinzu, and Leitner, there's also tremendous value in their engineering, testing, and support. When you're trusting a rack to secure expensive gear at highway speeds, quality and reliability should be primary considerations.
Do I need special tools to install a roof rack?
Almost all rack systems come with everything you need included in the box. Some platform-style racks may require additional tools if drilling and mounting modifications are needed for your vehicle.
Need Help Finding the Perfect Rack for Your Vehicle?
At Modula Racks, we understand that every vehicle and every user has unique needs. Use our Vehicle Fit tool to see exactly which systems will work with your specific vehicle's roof configuration, or contact our team for personalized recommendations.
Whether you're gearing up for weekend adventures or preparing for a cross-country expedition, choosing the right roof rack system is critical for safely transporting your gear while maintaining your vehicle's performance and appearance.
Related Products:
